Negative or critical feedback has the potential to affect an employee’s self-esteem or moral thereby having resulting effects to basic safety and security measures at work or in personal lives. Harsh and insensitive manner of providing feedback can lead to a feeling of worthlessness, incompetence, threat of exclusion, damaged self-confidence and esteem which can last for years.
Let us recollect the case of Junior Officer Ayushman (in our previous Issue of Sunday Review), who was critiqued for his work in front of his fellow crew members, leading him to feel humiliated, incompetent, and unworthy to be a part of his team and to overall unhappiness onboard.
In many situations, feedback may be given or taken wrongly for reasons such as where it is provided, the time and the state of mind of the person who is giving it, when it is provided or received, strong disappointing emotions instead of constructive feedback such as the clear intention and direction to help, personal choice i.e., like or dislike towards the person.
The previous article addressed how Ayushman should handle criticism in a more positive manner. However, in this article we provide suggestions for the way any Reporting Officer should give feedback.
Providing feedback is a skill in which the main ingredient is compassion. Compassion means concern for others. In the context of feedback, it means being thoughtful, sensitive and a well-wisher of the person whom feedback is being given to. It also means how you wish to help the person improve and to help one expand their comfort zones and their true potential.
The crux of effective feedback is Specific, Timely, Meaningful, goal-oriented and Candid with the Right Purpose in place.
- Specific:
It should be business focused. That is, primarily focusing on the area of relation. For instance, as a leader or teammate focus on work related skills. As a friend at work, you may have the liberty to provide feedback beyond work relations.
Ayushman’s reporting officer should be specific when providing feedback to him. This can be done by providing examples of where he should improve his work-related skills. - Timely:
Sometimes you would want to correct person through your actions like showing them the right way (handholding) or somedays you would want to privately sit and discuss with them, while on other days you would want to hear their thoughts/ideas and be an intellectual stimulant to them.
Timely also means you correct the actions at the right time rather than referring to it months later.
In this aspect, the reporting officer may correct Ayushman by showing how him how to work better but doing so in a way that does not make him feel demoralized. For e.g.: using polite words like, “Ayushman, let me show you how you can do this better.”
Alternatively, the reporting officer should speak to Ayushman in private. This would help him understand the younger officer better. - Meaningful: The idea is to show direction and share tips to improve shortcomings, that feedback receiver leaves the discussion with a plan of action in head. When providing feedback, it is always important to provide suggestions to improve. These suggestions may help receivers like Ayushman be more aware of their actions or view the feedback received differently.
- Goal Oriented:
Goal of the feedback is the impact/ end-outcome that you would want to see in a person.
Set a goal for the person whom feedback is being provided to. For instance, by the end of Ayushman’s tenure, he should show improvements in the following operational actions, or he may benefit from mentoring. Setting goals for Ayushman would encourage him to strive for improvement as well. - Candid:
Honesty is the key, but choosing words wisely is where one can incorporate compassion. You can be firm, strict but polite and non-aggressive at the same time.
Be honest and tell Ayushman how improving in the various areas would help him. It may help if the senior officer recounts his own experience and how learned from his mistakes. - Right Purpose:
Finally, the idea of providing feedback is to harm or hurt a person or correct their inappropriate or inefficient actions.
Refrain from being personal or using derogatory terms. If angered or upset, it is always good to disengage from the situation.
It is easy to speak with authority and familiarity onboard, especially as one spends hours and days together away from home. However, being professional and yet compassionate while providing feedback effectively remains key to cultivating a positive work culture and an effective team with crew who have good morale onboard.